Thursday, February 26, 2015

Violent Video Games Jury Decision

Both sides of attorneys that presented today did an impeccable job with the mock trial, however, in my mind, there was one side that clearly persuaded me with their evidence. Although the con side provided interesting points, I feel that violent video games do contribute to youth violence because of the fantastic evidence of the pro side. First, their point that video games desensitize violence was brilliantly backed up by their study about people and their brains reacting to violent images after playing video games, or not playing video games. I thought that this evidence showed a definite positive correlation between the reaction to violence with violent video games. In addition, they convinced me that violent video games raise aggression with the true story that they presented about the two 12-year-old girls who stabbed a girl 19 times because of playing Slenderman, and this made the whole case seem real to me. The fact that they provided this real life example of video games causing youth violence made me convinced that their argument was in the right. Furthermore, the attorneys persuaded me that video games glorify violence with the evidence that M (Mature) rated games were most recommended, and this made it very clear to me that violent video games are being promoted for young children. All of the evidence here made me realize that their case was right, and that is why I decide to choose the pro side today. The opposition still did a wonderful job, and their rebuttals were very strong, but in the end I thought that some of their evidence was not clearly linked to their arguments and were sometimes fuzzy to understand. For example, their evidence that the average player of the violent video games was 35 years old almost pushed me to believe their side, but when many new games were brought up and no explanation was given to the jury on the nature of the games, I was not convinced that the evidence was proving their case. For me, I found myself confused when the names of several games were said, and were claimed to be non-violent or help their case, but as I do not have any personal background on these games, I was not persuaded at all and could not see the relevance in the evidence. In the end, the pro side did a much better job of providing relevant and compelling evidence, and analyzing it to make it prove their case, while the defense had some good evidence but would have benefited from more analysis and more specific examples.