Monday, September 15, 2014

Summer Reading Essay

                 Historical fiction novels give insight on a historical time, but don't necessarily tell the truth. Many authors of this genre don't want to go through the hassle of researching the event before writing the novel. Therefore, not all historical fiction novels are accurate, and could be especially misleading to freshmen. In the historical fiction novel, Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein, an account of World War II is given by two girls who experienced the event, but they are, in actuality, fictional characters. This novel should not be read by freshman in high school because it is historically inaccurate, it is a diary entry that lies about the reality of events, and it contains many terms that make the novel hard to understand.    
        
                Code Name Verity should not be read by freshmen because it is historically inaccurate. For example, "Bear in mind that despite my somewhat exhaustive quest for historical accuracy, this book is not meant to be a good history but rather a good story" (Wein 334). From this evidence, it is clear that the novel isn't telling the complete and total truth about the actual events that occurred during World War II. The most logical conclusion one can draw from this is that freshmen could be misled about the events during the Holocaust because of the untruthful information, and therefore they should not read it. In addition, "The other thing I did make up is all the proper nouns" (Wein 335). Considering this example, one can see that the names of the planes, cities, air bases, and organizations that were mentioned in the book do not actually exist at all. The fact that the author would lie about the proper nouns in a book all the way from beginning to end proves that the book should not be read by freshmen. Freshmen should not read Code Name Verity because of its historical inaccuracy.

                This novel also is a complete and total lie because it is a diary entry written by a prisoner, so it contains lies about the actuality of what happened, and therefore freshmen could get confused on what is really the truth. For instance, "all I have done is buy myself time, time to write this" (Wein 200). This evidence is important because it shows how the book is made up entirely of diary entries written by a prisoner of war. The fact that a prisoner would be willing to lie about information to save their life illustrates why freshmen could easily get confused on what is truth in the book, and what is just a desperate lie. Furthermore, "they sent me here because I am so good at telling lies" (Wein 200). From this evidence, it is clear that since she is a spy, Julie is trained to lie about code and other information. The most logical conclusion that one can draw from this is that the entire diary entry from Julie is a lie, and therefore isn't a trustworthy source for information on a historical event. The lies in the diary entries that make up this book make it confusing for readers, and therefore an inadequate reading choice for freshmen.

                The novel Code Name Verity should not be read by freshmen because it is full of terms and proper nouns that make it hard to understand. For example, "the Moon Squadron use them for nighttime parachute drops, the Hudsons being bigger than Lizzies, so not suitable for short field landings" (Wein 140). From this evidence, it is clear that the strange and confusing plane lingo makes the book very hard to understand. The fact that a reader could become perplexed with the amount of prior knowledge about planes that is necessary to understand the novel, and therefore it would not have a place in the curriculum of freshmen. In addition, "one blustery autumn afternoon when the frantic days of the Battle of Britain had faded and flared into the explosive nights of the London Blitz, Dympna landed at RAF Maidsend in a twin-engined transport plane, delivering three pilots who were to fly broken Spitfires away for repair" (Wein 90). Considering this example, one can see that many uncommon proper nouns are used that make the text puzzling. The most logical conclusion one can draw from this is that reading this novel can be a challenge because of all the troubling language that is embedded into every page. All of the confusing terms and proper nouns make the novel Code Name Verity insufficient for freshmen.

              Code Name Verity by Elizabeth Wein should not be read by freshmen because of its historical inaccuracy, it is a diary entry, and it is difficult to understand. Although this novel is not necessarily the complete and total truth, it does give an emotional and physical account of what life would have been like during the Holocaust. The author does make the reader feel like they are part of the action, even though some of the aspects of the plot aren't real. This is for the most part typical for historical fiction novels, that some of the truth shines through the thick lies and fake proper nouns embedded in the book. Freshmen would have a very difficult time distinguishing between real and fake, and therefore historical fiction novels aren't the best match for their curriculum.

No comments:

Post a Comment