Thursday, October 16, 2014

Dialectical Journal for A Raisin in the Sun


“Not scrambled. (Ruth starts to scramble eggs)” (26).
(E) I think the author is trying to say that while Ruth and Walter Lee may have a playful relationship, it can also be a tough relationship. Ruth can tend to always want her way and is very bossy. The symbol in this excerpt is the scrambled eggs, and they represent the rejection that Walter gets when his ideas don’t work out. Ruth and Walter seem to have grown apart based on their opinions about what the best use of the insurance money is.
“He was mine too- and Travis’ grandfather- but the insurance money belongs to Mama” (38).
(CL) The information that is embedded in this passage is that Big Walter, Mama’s husband, passed away and the family is being given insurance money for consolation and the family is divided on how to use it. Beneatha believes that Mama should decide, while Walter wants to start a liquor store with the money. This has caused some bitterness amongst the family members. I also predict that since Walter is such a passionate man, he will become very frustrated and pessimistic when he doesn't get his way. This will cause the other family members to both become pessimistic because of his outlook on life, but also feel pity for him that his wish wasn't granted by the money that was supposed to solve all of their problems.


“(Underbreath) Express herself! (they laugh)” (48).
(Q) I really don’t understand this because it is traditional or common that the mother of a family sides with her children, but in this case, the mother is siding with her daughter-in-law and teasing her own daughter. Therefore, I have a few questions; Since when has the rest of the Younger family disliked Bennie? Why are they funding her education if they don’t agree with the way she is using their money? The answer to this, I believe, is that they will support her since she is her daughter, but they are afraid to cut her off because they have been funding her education for such a long period of time. Will Bennie decide to fight back against her family and say that she supports her decisions and wants to keep going with her method of education? To clarify, later in the novel, Beneatha goes to extremes to fight back against her mother, such as saying that she doesn't believe in God and that the whole idea of having God's presence in the house is ridiculous. And, is this mockery occurring because the rest of the family is envious of the privilege that Beneatha was given to receive an education?
"It's not mutilation!" (62).
(E) I really dislike this idea because it shows how uncomfortable and outcast that African Americans felt in this time in history when race was a huge societal issue. Beneatha changed the way that her hair was naturally curly from being African to make herself look more American by straightening it. Asagai, a native African, believes that she should change it back so she respects her origin. This shows how even a race that is being bullied is not united.This makes it easier for the white community to segregate against them, since they aren't even working together to fight back against their unfair stereotypes. This also shows the everlasting effects of slavery on Americans, which is unfortunately still alive today.
"You never understood that there is more than one kind of feeling that can exist between a man and a woman" (63).
(R) This excerpt shows how unfortunate that it is to be a black woman in America during the mid-1900s. Asagai is saying how only one feeling is needed between a man and a woman for a happy relationship, and that is attraction. On the other hand, Beneatha believes that there should be loyalty, sacrifice, dedication, acceptance, and an infinite number of other feelings that are necessary to a lasting relationship. The mid-1900s brought many restraints to being a black woman, which included the issues of assimilation, poverty, and individual choice. In this story, this will explain all of the restrictions and struggles that Mama, Ruth, and Beneatha will go through because they are black and female, and it represents the hardships of every African American women in America during the mid-1900s.
"I gave her a five-dollar down payment" (75).
(C) This passage reminds me of my deceased dog, Sakarrah, who was from Egypt. She was just a puppy, a street dog, when her mother abandoned her, and that is where my dad found and rescued her. In the story, Ruth is pregnant, but having another baby would be inconvenient and taxing at this time, since the family is already poor. The idea of abortion seemed reasonable to Ruth, so she had already given a down payment to a doctor who was to perform the operation. The only obstacle in the way of this procedure is Walter, who was forced to take action against the abortion by Mama and did nothing. He doesn't think that Ruth is making the most righteous and natural decision, but he is too frustrated, aggravated, and exhausted to reject a huge decision like this when the only thing on his mind is the liquor store.
"How can something that's natural be eccentric?" (80).
(E) When Beneatha decides to cut all of her hair off so she can regrow it in the natural African style, George Murchison decides that he doesn't like it. Beneatha defends it, saying that she is respecting her heritage, but George calls it eccentric, meaning that it is so unlike her that he doesn't even recognize her and it demonstrates someone who goes overboard with their culture when they learn about their heritage. Beneatha obviously took what Asagai said about assimilation very seriously and started to honor her African culture very quickly. The rest of the family views her transformation as ridiculous and goofy, but Beneatha acts like she knows much more than them and doesn't seem to understand or care about their judgment.
"Mama, there ain't no colored people living in Clybourne Park" (93).
(C) When Mama immediately spends a good portion of the money on a house in a white neighborhood, the rest of the family is shocked and they are doubting that they will enjoy the change at all. This passage reminds me of the novella, Of Mice and Men, when Crooks, the stable buck, who is also black, is separated and excluded from the other men on the ranch because of his race. The Youngers and Crooks feel similar in this situation because they are both being segregated against and are being excluded from the benefits of being white in America. The Younger family accepts the segregation, however, and their first thoughts when Mr. Lindner says they aren't welcome are not that they are mad at the white community and want to rebel, rather they think of their dream that is becoming smaller and smaller and somewhat accept their place in society.
“She goes to her plant, which has remained on the table, looks at it, picks it up, and takes it to the windowsill and sites it outside, and she stands and looks at it a long moment” (139).
(E) The plant that Mama has kept for the duration of the play and more is an old, shriveled plant, but it is also a plant that is loved. This is a huge symbol for the situation that the Youngers are in and have been for all of their life, because of their race and being poor. The plant symbolizes their everlasting struggles, and their lingering exposure to suffering. It serves as a reminder of their place in this world. The fact that the plant never grows is a representation that they will never break out of the societal hierarchy at which they stand, and the plant also can illustrate their forgotten dreams, that are put to waste because of the difficulty that it takes to higher their place in society. Furthermore, the detail that Mama always takes it with her and goes to the plant in times of adversity shows that it reminds her of her dreams and is a motivation to keep going to try and accomplish her dreams.
“And we have decided to move into our house” (148).
(R) The author decides to end the book with this event; the decision by Walter to go along with the family and buy the house that Mama has always dreamed of, because she wanted to show the sacrifices that people should be willing to take for their loved ones. The quote is illustrating Walter’s redemption for being hostile and unwelcoming when he didn’t get his way. In a broader sense, this quote shows how people have to make sacrifices for their family and the greater good of the people. Sometimes it is okay to let go of a dream if one knows the dream isn’t the right thing for family, and the important thing is for people to admit that their wishes don’t grant the wishes of others. Mama’s house was a dream that could benefit the entire Younger family because it would give them a chance to break free from their old, unkempt current living quarters and use the money to buy a new, civilized home. Walter’s dream to buy a liquor store didn’t benefit the greater good of the people because it was a selfish wish and the store wouldn’t be successful because of his lack of expertise and his sudden decision to want the business.

No comments:

Post a Comment