9) For the novel, To Kill a Mockingbird, in my opinion, the book is better than the movie. For example, when the jury's decision of the verdict of Tom Robinson was made in the book, I felt that the situation was much more devastating and pessimistic than in the movie, which seemed rushed and less emotional in comparison. The fact that this event is the deciding point in the way that Jem and Scout view their society and when they realize how unfair it is shows how this moment should have received more attention in the movie than it did. In addition, there were several characters left out in the movie that added much more detail and clarity to the plot in the book. Aunt Alexandra, Miss Caroline, and Dolphus Raymond all did not show up in the movie, especially Aunt Alexandra because of the way that she challenged the current lifestyle of Scout and the Finches. These characters made the plot of the book much more clear than that of the movie, and it was much easier to understand the book. Overall, I think that I would not have enjoyed the movie very much if I hadn't already read the book. For the novel, To Kill a Mockingbird, in my opinion, the book is better than the movie
7) There are several things that are gained and lost because of the film being shot in the third person rather than Scout's point of view. For instance, something that is gained from the third person point of view is that it is much easier to see what is going on in the story. One event that was much easier to understand in the third person was when Bob Ewell follows Scout and Jem after the Halloween play and attacks them. The first person account of the event was very vague and one-sided in the book because it only describes what Scout saw, not what actually happened. Since it is from the third person, the camera shoots from a place that gives an adequate view of what is happening. However, in the first person perspective given by Scout in the book, the only account of events was given from Scout and the viewers may only imagine what is happening based off of what Scout sees, and not a complete view. It is therefore easier to interpret the story line from the third person in the movie. On the other hand, something that is lost from the third person perspective is the fact that it is harder to understand the characters' thoughts and feelings. For example, when Scout fights Walter Cunningham after school after she is humiliated one day, the viewers may have been confused why she felt so strongly against the way that Walter acted. In the first person view of Scout, the reader can see what is going on in Scout's mind that causes her to lash out at Walter in the way she did. In the book, the first person point of view allowed for the reader to know exactly how Scout feels in different situations throughout the plot, but in the movie, since the narration is not given by an actual person, it is much harder to imagine things from Scout's point of view and understand how she feels. Several things are gained or lost because of the perspective of the film versus the book.
No comments:
Post a Comment